State Vs Navien Tankless Water Heater: A Pro’S Guide To Choosing

ByDavid Clark

Let’s be honest—that sinking feeling when the shower suddenly turns ice-cold is one of life’s little miseries. Or maybe it’s the dread of opening your utility bill after a long winter, knowing your old, clunky tank water heater has been working overtime. You know there’s a better way, and you’ve probably heard whispers about the magic of endless hot water from a tankless unit.

I promise that by the end of this guide, you’ll have a clear, expert understanding of two of the biggest names in the game. We’re going to put them head-to-head in a detailed state vs navien tankless water heater comparison, breaking down everything that matters to you as a homeowner.

We’ll walk through their technology, performance, cost, and reliability. You’ll get the real-world pros and cons of each, so you can confidently choose the perfect on-demand water heater for your home, your family, and your budget.

Meet the Contenders: A Quick Intro to State and Navien

Before we dive into the technical details, let’s get to know our two competitors. Think of them as having two different philosophies for achieving the same goal: providing you with reliable, on-demand hot water.

State Water Heaters: The Tried-and-True Workhorse

State is a classic American brand that has been a household name for decades. As part of the A.O. Smith family, they have a long-standing reputation for building durable, no-frills equipment that simply gets the job done. Many plumbers and technicians grew up installing State products.

Their approach to tankless technology is grounded in this history. They focus on robust construction and straightforward, reliable performance. A State unit is often seen as a dependable, familiar choice that prioritizes longevity over flashy features.

Navien Water Heaters: The High-Tech Innovator

Navien, on the other hand, is a South Korean company that burst onto the scene with a focus on cutting-edge technology and maximum efficiency. They are pioneers in making high-efficiency condensing technology the standard for residential tankless heaters.

A Navien unit is packed with features like built-in recirculation systems, Wi-Fi connectivity, and advanced diagnostics. They are designed for homeowners who want the absolute best in energy savings and modern conveniences, making them a leader in the sustainable and eco-friendly state vs navien tankless water heater conversation.

Deep Dive: What Sets State Tankless Water Heaters Apart?

When you choose a State tankless water heater, you’re investing in a legacy of reliability. Let’s break down what that means for you.

Built to Last: Durability and Simple Design

State’s biggest strength is its straightforward engineering. They use high-quality components and heat exchangers designed for a long service life. There are fewer complex electronics, which for some homeowners means fewer potential points of failure down the road.

This simplicity is a key part of their appeal. If you value a product that is easy for most professionals to understand and service, State is a very strong contender.

Performance and Flow Rate

State offers a range of non-condensing tankless water heaters that provide excellent hot water output. They are measured in Gallons Per Minute (GPM), which tells you how much hot water the unit can produce at once. A typical State model can easily run two showers and a sink simultaneously in a moderate climate.

While they may not always have the highest efficiency ratings, their performance is consistent and powerful, making them a great upgrade from a traditional tank heater.

Installation and Serviceability

Because State is such a well-established brand, finding a qualified technician to install or service your unit is often easier. Many plumbers are familiar with their design and can quickly diagnose issues, which can sometimes lead to lower labor costs for repairs.

The Innovator’s Edge: Exploring Navien Tankless Technology

Navien built its reputation on pushing the boundaries of what a tankless water heater can do. Their units are designed from the ground up for maximum efficiency and user convenience.

The Power of Condensing Technology

This is Navien’s signature feature. A traditional, non-condensing heater (like many State models) loses a lot of heat through hot exhaust gases. A condensing heater, like all Navien models, has a second heat exchanger that captures much of that wasted heat.

See also  Navien Tankless Water Heater Error Code 027 - Your Step-By-Step

What does this mean for you? First, incredible energy efficiency—often with a Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) of 0.95 or higher. This translates directly to lower monthly gas bills. Second, the exhaust is much cooler, allowing for less expensive PVC or polypropylene venting instead of costly stainless steel.

Advanced Features and Smart Controls

Navien units come loaded with smart tech. Many models in their NPE-A2 series include a built-in recirculation pump and buffer tank. This brilliant feature, called ComfortFlow®, eliminates the “cold water sandwich” effect and dramatically reduces the wait time for hot water at the tap—all without needing a complex external pump setup.

Plus, with their NaviLink™ Wi-Fi control system, you can adjust temperatures, monitor usage, and receive diagnostic notifications right on your smartphone. This is a huge benefit for tech-savvy homeowners.

A Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Choice

The high efficiency of Navien heaters makes them a fantastic choice for an eco-friendly state vs navien tankless water heater solution. By burning less natural gas to heat the same amount of water, you significantly reduce your home’s carbon footprint. Their compliance with stringent air quality standards further solidifies their position as a green-conscious brand.

The Ultimate Showdown: State vs Navien Tankless Water Heater Head-to-Head

Alright, let’s put them side-by-side. Here’s our state vs navien tankless water heater guide to the key decision-making factors.

Energy Efficiency and Long-Term Savings

Winner: Navien

There’s no contest here. Navien’s condensing technology gives it a massive advantage, with UEF ratings typically ranging from 0.95 to 0.97. State’s non-condensing models are usually in the 0.81-0.82 range. Over the 15-20 year lifespan of the unit, a Navien will save you significantly more on your energy bills, often enough to offset its higher initial price.

Upfront Cost vs. Lifetime Value

Winner: State (for upfront cost), Navien (for lifetime value)

A State tankless water heater generally has a lower purchase price. If your budget is tight, it’s a very attractive option. However, when you factor in the long-term energy savings from a Navien, the total cost of ownership for the Navien is often lower. You have to decide if you want to save now or save more over time.

Warranty and Customer Support

Winner: It’s a Tie (with a catch)

Both companies offer excellent warranties, typically around 15 years for the heat exchanger and 5 years for parts. The most important factor here isn’t the brand, but the installer. An improper installation by an unqualified person can void your warranty with either company. Always use a licensed, certified professional.

Performance in Cold Climates

Winner: Navien

In colder regions, the incoming ground water is, well, colder! This means your water heater has to work much harder to raise the temperature to your desired setting. Navien’s more powerful and efficient condensing system gives it an edge in maintaining high GPM flow rates even when the input water is frigid.

A Practical Care Guide: Maintenance and Common Problems

No matter which brand you choose, proper care is essential. Following this state vs navien tankless water heater care guide will ensure your unit runs smoothly for years.

Essential Annual Maintenance Best Practices

The single most important maintenance task is descaling, also known as flushing the unit. Mineral deposits (scale) from hard water can build up inside the heat exchanger, reducing efficiency and eventually causing damage.

  1. Turn off all power and water supplies to the unit.
  2. Connect a circulation pump and hoses to the service valves.
  3. Circulate a descaling solution (like food-grade white vinegar) through the unit for about 45-60 minutes.
  4. Flush thoroughly with clean water before restoring normal service.

You should also clean the inlet water filter and, for Navien units, check and clean the condensate trap. This is one of the most important state vs navien tankless water heater tips we can offer.

See also  Navien On Demand Water Heater 03 Code: Your Step-By-Step

Troubleshooting Common Problems with State vs Navien Tankless Water Heaters

If you experience issues, don’t panic! Modern units are great at self-diagnosing and will display an error code.

  • No Hot Water: First, check the error code on the display. Then, confirm the unit has power, the gas valve is open, and your home has gas service.
  • Fluctuating Temperatures: This could be a flow rate issue (trying to use too many fixtures at once) or, in older homes, a pressure-balancing issue in the plumbing.
  • Loud Noises: A rumbling or kettling sound often indicates scale buildup that needs to be flushed out immediately.

Safety First: While checking error codes is safe, never attempt to open the unit’s casing or service gas components yourself. For anything beyond a simple reset, call a qualified technician.

Frequently Asked Questions About State and Navien Heaters

Which brand is better for a small home or condo?

For smaller homes with one or two bathrooms, a non-condensing State unit can be a very cost-effective and perfectly adequate choice. Its lower upfront cost makes a lot of sense when demand for hot water isn’t extremely high.

Do Navien heaters require more maintenance?

Not necessarily more, but slightly different. Both units need annual descaling. A Navien also requires you to check its condensate drain to ensure it’s clear, which is a very simple step. The benefits of its efficiency far outweigh this minor additional check.

Is the higher cost of a Navien unit worth it?

For most homeowners, yes. If you plan to stay in your home for five years or more, the monthly energy savings from a Navien will typically pay back the initial price difference and then continue to save you money for the life of the unit. It’s an investment in lower utility bills.

Can I install a tankless water heater myself?

We strongly advise against this. Installing a tankless water heater involves working with high-voltage electricity, gas lines, and plumbing. A mistake can be incredibly dangerous and will void your manufacturer’s warranty. This is a job for a licensed and insured professional, period.

The Final Verdict: Which Heater Is Right for You?

So, after this deep dive into the state vs navien tankless water heater debate, who comes out on top? The truth is, the “best” unit is the one that best fits your specific needs and priorities.

Choose State if: Your primary concern is upfront budget, you live in a moderate climate, and you value a simple, robust machine that any experienced plumber can service.

Choose Navien if: Your priority is maximum energy efficiency, long-term cost savings, and the latest technology. If you want smart features, faster hot water delivery, and a smaller carbon footprint, Navien is the clear leader.

Upgrading to a tankless water heater is one of the best improvements you can make for your home’s comfort and efficiency. By weighing these factors, you’re now equipped to make an informed decision that will bring you endless hot water for years to come.

Stay safe, and stay comfortable!

David Clark
Latest posts by David Clark (see all)