Navien Tankless Water Heater Internal Vs External Recirculation: Your

Are you tired of the morning ritual of turning on the shower and waiting… and waiting… for the hot water to finally arrive? You’re not just losing precious time; you’re watching gallons of perfectly good water—and money—go right down the drain. It’s a common frustration that leaves many homeowners wondering if there’s a better way.

We’re here to promise you that there absolutely is. Navien, a leader in tankless technology, offers two powerful solutions to this exact problem, but they can be confusing. This guide will give you a clear, expert breakdown of the navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation debate.

Get ready to dive in. We’ll explore exactly how each system delivers instant hot water, compare their pros and cons head-to-head, and give you the practical knowledge to decide which setup is the perfect fit for your home, your budget, and your lifestyle. Say goodbye to the wait and hello to on-demand comfort.

What is Hot Water Recirculation and Why Does It Matter?

Before we jump into the internal vs. external debate, let’s quickly cover the “why.” In a standard plumbing system, the water sitting in your pipes cools down after you turn off the tap. The next time you need hot water, you have to push all that cold, stagnant water out first. This is what causes the delay.

A hot water recirculation system solves this by creating a loop. It gently and periodically circulates hot water from the heater through your pipes and back again. This ensures that warm water is always close to your faucets and showers, ready the moment you need it.

The benefits are huge. You drastically reduce water waste, which is a cornerstone of any eco-friendly navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation strategy. You also get the immediate convenience of on-demand hot water, a small luxury that makes a big difference every single day.

The Navien Internal Recirculation System (NPE-A2 Series): The “All-in-One” Solution

Think of Navien’s “A” series (like the popular NPE-A2) as the premium, integrated option. These units are designed from the ground up with recirculation built right into the chassis. It’s a clean, elegant, and powerful solution for homeowners who want a seamless system.

How Internal Recirculation Works

The magic of the NPE-A2 models lies in two key components that other models lack: a built-in recirculation pump and a small buffer tank.

The pump is the heart of the system, pushing water through the loop. The buffer tank pre-heats a small amount of water, which helps eliminate the “cold water sandwich” effect—that brief shot of cold water you sometimes get with other tankless heaters. This setup provides an incredibly smooth and consistent hot water experience.

For homes without a dedicated pipe for the water to loop back (a “return line”), Navien uses a brilliant accessory called the NaviCirc™ valve. This small valve gets installed under the sink farthest from the water heater. It creates a crossover, allowing the hot water to use the cold water line as its path back to the heater, completing the loop without needing expensive new plumbing.

Pros of Internal Recirculation

Seamless Integration: Everything is contained in one sleek unit. There are no external parts to wire or plumb in, making for a very clean-looking installation.
Simple Operation: The pump and its settings are all controlled directly from the water heater’s main control panel. No separate timers or controls are needed.
Optimized Performance: Because the pump and heater were designed to work together, the system is highly efficient and effective right out of the box.
Warranty Coverage: The entire system, including the pump, is covered under Navien’s single, comprehensive warranty.

Cons of Internal Recirculation

Higher Upfront Cost: The NPE-A2 models with the built-in components are more expensive than their standard “S2” series counterparts.
Model Specific: This feature is only available on the premium “A” series. You can’t add it to a standard model later.

The Navien External Recirculation System (NPE-S2 Series + NaviCirc™): The “Flexible” Approach

Now, let’s look at the other side of the coin. Navien’s “S” series (like the NPE-S2) are their standard, high-efficiency tankless models. They don’t have a built-in pump, but they are fully capable of recirculation with the addition of an external kit like the NaviCirc™.

This approach offers more flexibility and is a fantastic way to add the convenience of recirculation to a standard tankless model, either at the time of installation or even down the road.

How External Recirculation Works

With this setup, you have the standard NPE-S2 water heater and a separate, external pump. The NaviCirc™ accessory is a kit that includes both the crossover valve (for under the sink) and the external pump that gets installed near the water heater.

The pump is wired for power and plumbed into the hot and cold lines near the unit. When activated, it does the exact same job as the internal pump: it pulls hot water through the pipes, using the cold water line as a return path via the crossover valve. The main difference is that the pump is a distinct component outside the water heater’s main body.

Pros of External Recirculation

Lower Upfront Unit Cost: The standard NPE-S2 water heater is less expensive than the NPE-A2, making the initial purchase more budget-friendly.
Flexibility: You can choose to add recirculation at any time. This is a great option if you want to upgrade later or if your budget is tight initially.
Retrofit-Friendly: This is often the go-to solution for replacing an existing tankless water heater where an “A” model might be overkill or not in the budget.

Cons of External Recirculation

More Complex Installation: The installer needs to mount, plumb, and wire the external pump. While not difficult for a pro, it does involve more steps and potential points of failure.
Separate Component: You have an additional piece of equipment to maintain and potentially service in the future.
Aesthetics: The installation isn’t as clean as the all-in-one “A” series, with an external pump and wiring visible near the unit.

Navien Tankless Water Heater Internal vs External Recirculation: A Head-to-Head Comparison

So, how do you choose? The decision really comes down to your specific situation. This navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation guide is designed to help you weigh the factors that matter most to you.

Installation Complexity and Cost

On paper, the internal system seems simpler because it’s one unit. However, the unit itself costs more. The external system requires more labor to install the separate pump, but the water heater is cheaper. In the end, the total installed cost can often be very similar. It’s crucial to get a quote from your plumber that specifies the model and any accessories like NaviCirc™.

Performance and Efficiency

Both systems deliver fantastic results and solve the problem of waiting for hot water. The internal NPE-A2 system may have a slight performance edge due to the buffer tank, which ensures perfectly stable temperatures from the very first second. Both systems are highly efficient, and the energy used by the pump is minimal compared to the water savings, making either choice a sustainable navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation option.

System Longevity and Maintenance

Both Navien water heaters are built to last. The primary difference is the pump. With an internal system, it’s one less separate part to worry about. With an external system, the pump is another component that could eventually need service. Following a proper navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation care guide, which includes annual descaling, is key to longevity for either setup.

How to Choose: Key Factors for Your Home

Feeling stuck? Don’t worry. Let’s walk through the key questions that will point you to the right answer for your home.

Do You Have a Dedicated Recirculation Line?

This is the first and most important question. A dedicated return line is a separate pipe that runs from the farthest fixture back to the water heater. If you are building a new home or doing a major remodel, we strongly recommend installing one. If you have one, both internal and external systems work beautifully, and installation is simpler. If you don’t, you will need the NaviCirc™ crossover valve regardless of which system you choose.

New Installation vs. Retrofit

For a brand-new installation in a new home, the clean, integrated NPE-A2 internal system is often the preferred choice. It’s elegant and purpose-built. For a retrofit where you’re replacing an older heater, the NPE-S2 with an external NaviCirc™ kit can be a more practical and cost-effective solution.

Your Budget

Budget is always a factor. If the lower upfront cost of the NPE-S2 unit allows you to get into a high-efficiency tankless system, it’s a fantastic choice. You can always add the external pump later. If your budget allows for the premium NPE-A2, the integration and convenience are hard to beat.

A Note on DIY vs. Professional Installation

While this guide is for everyone, installing a tankless water heater involves gas lines, high-voltage electricity, plumbing, and proper venting. This is not a DIY project. For your safety and to ensure your warranty remains valid, always hire a licensed and insured plumber or HVAC technician for the installation. Understanding the difference between these systems helps you have a more informed conversation with your pro.

Common Problems and Best Practices

Once your system is up and running, it should be very reliable. However, here are a few tips to keep in mind, covering some common problems with navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation.

Issue: Hot Water Still Takes a While

First, check the recirculation settings. Navien offers an “intelligent” mode that learns your usage patterns and a “constant” mode. Make sure it’s set to your preference. Also, have your plumber confirm the NaviCirc™ valve under the sink is installed correctly and functioning.

Issue: Water Isn’t Hot Enough at the Farthest Faucet

This could be a sign of a crossover issue where cold water is mixing in. It could also mean your hot water pipes are uninsulated and losing a lot of heat, especially if they run through a cold crawlspace or attic.

Best Practices for Peak Performance

Insulate Your Pipes: This is one of the best and cheapest upgrades you can make. Insulating at least the first 10-15 feet of hot water pipes coming off the heater will make a huge difference in performance and efficiency.
Use the Intelligent Mode: For most families, the “intelligent pre-heating” mode is the perfect balance of convenience and energy savings. It learns when you typically use hot water and runs the pump accordingly.
Schedule Annual Maintenance: Just like your car, your tankless water heater needs a tune-up. Schedule a professional descaling service annually to keep it running at peak efficiency for years to come. This is one of the most important navien tankless water heater internal vs external recirculation best practices.

Frequently Asked Questions About Navien Recirculation Systems

Can I add an internal recirculation pump to my existing Navien NPE-S2?

No, the internal pump and buffer tank are factory-installed components of the NPE-A2 series. To add recirculation to an NPE-S2, you must use an external pump kit like the NaviCirc™.

Does running a recirculation pump use a lot of electricity?

Modern recirculation pumps are incredibly efficient and use very little electricity, often less than a 25-watt lightbulb. When used in an intelligent or scheduled mode, the energy cost is minimal and typically far outweighed by the savings from not wasting water.

What is the “cold water sandwich” effect?

This is a phenomenon specific to tankless heaters where you get a brief burst of cold water in the middle of a hot shower. It happens when you turn the water off and then quickly back on. The buffer tank in the Navien NPE-A2 series is specifically designed to eliminate this issue.

Do I need a dedicated return line for Navien recirculation to work?

No, you don’t! While a dedicated return line is considered the “gold standard” for plumbing, Navien’s NaviCirc™ crossover valve allows you to create a recirculation loop using your existing cold water line as the return path. This makes it possible to enjoy recirculation in almost any home.

Choosing between Navien’s internal and external recirculation systems is a great problem to have—it means you’re on your way to ending the wait for hot water for good. The internal NPE-A2 system offers a seamless, premium, all-in-one solution. The external approach with an NPE-S2 provides flexibility and a lower initial cost.

The right choice depends entirely on your home’s plumbing, your budget, and whether you’re starting fresh or retrofitting. By understanding these key differences, you can work with your trusted HVACR professional to select the perfect system that brings a little bit of luxury and a whole lot of eco-friendly convenience to your daily routine.

Stay safe, save water, and stay comfortable!

Author
Recent Posts

David Clark

Founder & Lead HVAC Specialist at HVACRLY

David Clark is the founder of HVACrly and a certified HVAC specialist with 10+ years working on residential and light-commercial systems. He turns complex heating, cooling, ventilation, and refrigeration topics into clear, actionable guides focused on safety and energy efficiency. When he’s not on a service call, he’s testing tools and writing step-by-step tutorials.